21 Secret Pal Thanksgiving Gift Ideas to Show Your Appreciation

Tap on a product image to see more.

Amazon Affiliate Disclaimer: As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases made through links on this site at no extra cost to you.

  1. Wine Stoppers Set - Help your secret pal preserve the freshness of their favorite wines with this set of 2 stainless steel wine stoppers. The silicone seal ensures an airtight fit, making them the ideal wine saver accessory.
  2. Scented Candle - Create a cozy and relaxing atmosphere with this premium scented candle. With scents of oud wood and lemon flower, it's the perfect gift to show your appreciation to your secret pal.
  3. Charles Wysocki Jigsaw Puzzle - Challenge your secret pal's puzzle-solving skills with this 1000 piece jigsaw puzzle featuring the artwork of Charles Wysocki. A great way to spend quality time during the Thanksgiving holiday.
  4. Squirrel Nut Bowl - Add a whimsical touch to your secret pal's snack time with this ceramic squirrel nut bowl. It's not only a functional serving dish but also a charming decoration that will bring a smile to their face.
  5. Conversation Starter Game - Encourage meaningful conversations and create lasting memories with this family gathering conversation starter game. It's the perfect gift to spark interesting discussions during Thanksgiving get-togethers.
  6. Movie Night Popcorn Variety Pack - Treat your secret pal to a delicious movie night with this variety pack. It includes 3 packs of non-GMO popcorn kernels and 5 gourmet popcorn snack seasonings for a tasty and fun movie experience.
  7. Glass Cocktail Shaker with Recipes - Shake up some fun with this glass cocktail shaker. It comes with a strainer lid and is printed with 6 cocktail recipes, making it a stylish and practical gift for your secret pal who enjoys mixing drinks.
  8. Natural Wood Slices Craft Kit - This craft kit includes 30 unfinished wood slices that can be used for various arts and crafts projects. Perfect for creating personalized ornaments or DIY decorations.
  9. "The Pioneer Woman Cooks―A Year of Holidays" Recipe Book - This cookbook is filled with 140 step-by-step recipes for simple and scrumptious holiday celebrations. A perfect gift for your secret pal who loves cooking and hosting gatherings.
  10. Nutcracker Ornament Set - Add a touch of holiday charm to your secret pal's home with this 10-piece nutcracker ornament set. Each ornament is beautifully crafted and will make a festive addition to any Christmas tree.
  11. Reversible Sherpa Fleece Throw Blanket - Stay cozy and warm during the colder months with this reversible sherpa fleece throw blanket from Eddie Bauer. Its soft and plush material is perfect for snuggling up on the couch or adding a touch of comfort to any room decor.
  12. Hilarious Party Game - Bring laughter and entertainment to any Thanksgiving gathering with the "Relative Insanity" party game by comedian Jeff Foxworthy. Designed for ages 14 and up, this game is perfect for a fun-filled evening with friends and family.
  13. Fall & Thanksgiving Kitchen Apron - Add a festive touch to your Thanksgiving cooking with this women's kitchen apron from DII. With adjustable long waist ties and a "Thankful" design, this apron is both functional and stylish.
  14. "The Art of the Cheese Plate" Book - For the cheese connoisseur in your life, "The Art of the Cheese Plate" is a must-have. This book offers a guide to creating beautiful and delicious cheese plates, complete with pairings, recipes, and expert advice.
  15. Favorite Jam Collection - This four-piece jam collection from Stonewall Kitchen is the perfect gift for someone who loves a sweet and flavorful spread. With flavors like strawberry, wild Maine blueberry, raspberry peach champagne, and sour cherry, this set is sure to delight taste buds.
  16. Beanie Wine Stopper - This adorable beanie-shaped wine stopper is a fun and cute addition to any wine lover's collection. It comes in a pack of two and makes for a great conversation starter at any gathering.
  17. Spiced Apple Cider Tea - Indulge in the flavors of fall with this spiced apple cider tea. Infused with cinnamon and cloves, this caffeine-free herbal tea is the perfect warm beverage for a cozy Thanksgiving celebration.
  18. Hot Cinnamon Spice Tea - Warm up this Thanksgiving with a cup of delicious hot cinnamon spice tea. Made with black tea, orange, and sweet clove, this flavorful blend will add a touch of coziness to the holiday season.
  19. Electric Carving Knife Set - Make Thanksgiving dinner prep a breeze with this electric carving knife set. It includes reciprocating serrated stainless steel blades, an ergonomic design storage case, and even a fork. Perfect for carving meats, poultry, bread, and more!
  20. Conversation Starter Questions - Spice up your Thanksgiving gathering with these thought-provoking conversation starter questions. Perfect for creating memorable moments and engaging discussions with family and friends.
  21. Thanksgiving Wine Bottle Labels - Add a touch of humor to your Thanksgiving dinner with these festive wine bottle label stickers. Perfect for decorating wine bottles and bringing a smile to your guests' faces.